William Katz: Urgent Agenda
|
||
|
SNIPPETS, our daily collection of short items and comments, is here. --------------------------------------------- BARACK OBAMA'S FIRST HUNDRED DAYS is on hiatus until after the conventions. We've gone through the first 50 days. The conventions and the launch of the fall campaign will provide new material, new absurdities, and allow us to finish the first 100 days just before the election. An archive containing the first 50 days is here. --------------------------------------------- Our next subscription drive will be in October. However, readers are invited to subscribe at any time. Subscriptions are voluntary, but are critical to keeping us going. Subscribe in the right-hand column. --------------------------------------------
THURSDAY, AUGUST 28, 2008
11:58 p.m. ET: I'm now reviewing the text of Obama's speech. You know, it's like one of those extended warranties from a no-name electronics store. Looks good at first, as long as you don't think about what's been left out. The more I read, the more deceptive and inaccurate it becomes. McCain could take this apart in a debate. 11:27 p.m. ET: I just saw that John McCain ad again, the one where he congratulates Barack Obama on his nomination. Earlier I said I could live without it, and that I thought it came off as contrived. I must say, though, that coming after Obama's attacks on McCain tonight, McCain's gracious congratulations sounded good, and were a solid contrast. Maybe I was wrong. Maybe it was a fine idea, even a masterstroke. You decide. 10:58 p.m. ET: Obama has now ended. He delivered a solid political speech. If you get into details, of course, things get murky. But details were not what this speech was about. I think Obama will get a reasonable bounce from his inspirational speech. Now it will be up to John McCain to answer it, point by point, to deflate the balloon and prove that the emperor-in-waiting has no clothes. McCain's campaign has been very sharp recently. It must get even sharper, and stay that way. 10:42 p.m. ET: Obama turns hokey. "This election has never been about me. It's about you," he says. Oh, please. 10:44 p.m. ET: Obama has gone through a fairly standard laundry list of Democratic programs, but he's stated the case as well as a liberal can. Now he's attacking John McCain on national security, a dangerous course begun by Joe Biden last night. McCain will be able to answer this easily. Many of the statements Obama is making about McCain's positions are misleading. Now Obama's rhetoric is starting to soar into the stratosphere. He's making foreign-policy promises that are fine, if you're twelve. But anyone with even reasonable familiarity with international affairs will see that many of Obama's promises are simplistic and even silly. He will not heal the world in five minutes, or even ten. 10:36 p.m. ET: Obama is now saying what he'll do as president. He introduced this segment by saying he wanted to define exactly what he meant by "change." The audience cheered, a recognition of the fact that lack of specifics has haunted the Obama campaign. 10:27 p.m. ET: Obama speaks. With a prepared speech, he's fine. A gifted speaker. The substance thus far, however, isn't all that compelling. He's now attacking McCain, and some of his comments are over the top. Obama began this campaign by pledging to be a different kind of candidate. As of now, in this speech, he's a conventional attack dog. It isn't all that appealing. 10:11 p.m. ET: The introductory Obama film is on now. Look, it's slick and professional. All these films are pretty much the same. The candidate is perfect, he's the one, he is pure and good, he is your only decent choice. How can you vote against him? 9:55 p.m. ET: Obama will be speaking soon. The stadium is filled. I'm looking at the set, which was the subject of considerable criticism. Some felt it was too grand, too pompous. I'm not sure I agree. I've been in television, as many of you know, and things appear quite different on the screen than they do "in person." This set, viewed on TV, looks within bounds to me. 9:25 p.m. ET: Joe Biden is now making a surprise appearance before the crowd at Invesco Field. His remarks seem like a retread of his remarks last night. This is not good. It's a turnoff, and Joe Biden has made an art of turning off audiences. 9:17 p.m. ET: I've now seen the McCain ad, running tonight, graciously congratulating Barack Obama on his nomination. Okay, it's a classy thing to do, but, frankly, I could have done without it. It looks contrived and staged, and that's not John McCain. It will make no difference. 8:46 p.m. ET: Al Gore is now speaking at Invesco Field. I am not listening. I know the world is burning up, we are all doomed, and the 2000 election was stolen by the Supreme Court, which is controlled by Halliburton. Why should I listen? 8:30 p.m. ET: Obama will speak at 10 p.m. ET. I've read some excerpts from his speech, released by his campaign. It strikes me as a skillful job, more nuts 'n bolts than most of Obama's sermons. But I'll withhold judgment until I hear the words come from Obama's mouth. A speech is spoken, and how it's spoken is often more important than what it says. So stand by.
We're always happy to update and correct reports, and our readers are fantastic in supplying good information. The link to the presidential exhibit is here.
MORE ART Posted at 3:25 p.m. ET Such culture we have for you today. Earlier we reported on plans for the artistic design of the set from which the saint will bless the masses tonight in Denver. Now readers Jean Spik and Katherine Winterer point out that the set designer also designs for Britney Spears. Remember when John McCain compared Barack's celebrity status to that of Spears, and was ridiculed? Apparently John was on to something. And it doesn't stop there. London's Daily Mail is running this picture, which they say is a mock-up of Air Force One being delivered to Invesco Field, where Obama will accept the nomination. Look, I can't confirm this. But it's too juicy to ignore. The fun factor overwhelms me.
If the Dems are smart, and occasionally they are, they'd fly the plane off to some undisclosed location, and leave it there. I hope they use it. So tacky, so fun. August 28, 2008. Permalink
TRACKERS Posted at 1:26 p.m. ET Both trackers are now out for today. As reported earlier, Rasmussen has the race tied, but reports a trend toward Obama in the last two nights of polling. However, Gallup is already reporting a sizable bump for Obama. Gallup had Obama up one yesterday, but has him up six points today. There is no need to panic. Indeed, I would expect Obama's bump to grow, even to ten or twelve points. This is fairly normal for conventions, and we must cautiously assume that the McCain convention next week will reverse the tide. I stress "assume." It hasn't happened yet. We should also note that Gallup polls registered voters, whereas Rasmussen polls likely voters. Because of the conventions, I don't think the polls will settle down until mid-September. Until then, we'll have to ride the roller coaster. August 28, 2008. Permalink
ARTISTIC NOTES Posted at 1:16 p.m. ET Urgent Agenda readers are cultured, artistic, and sensitive, so I thought you'd like an update on how the aesthetics of tonight's speech by Barack Obama are being handled. The New York Times, which respects our feelings and vulnerabilities, and understands our anxieties, reports:
But...
Yes, he feels our pain, like another president, but the setting, the mood, must show it.
Some 75,000 fans will be asked to text message? I'm moved. The sense of discipline. The lockstep thinking. Leni Riefenstahl would be so proud.
Well, when the candidate doesn't have an air of stateliness, I guess you do Hollywood sets.
Fellas, you're not running for the nomination anymore. Get that text message?
It's just like the Obama crowd to try to predict the weather weeks in advance. They seem to feel they have a direct connection somewhere.
Especially when you haven't got one. Why do I think we're about to see an embarrassment? August 28, 2008. Permalink BULLETIN: The first tracker is now out (at 9:34 a.m.). Rasmussen, which had McCain up by one yesterday, reports a tie today. Tracking polls are conducted over a three-night period. Rasmussen reports that Obama's numbers have improved in the last two nights, reflecting events at the convention. Rasmussen projects that the convention will give Obama a modest bounce. Of course, the Republicans meet on Monday.
LAST NIGHT IN DENVER Posted at 7:10 a.m. ET (Note: An earlier version of this story predicted rain in Denver tonight. The forecast is now for clear weather.) The Democrats had a good night last night. John Kerry spoke and no one listened, which is good news for the Dems. Bill Clinton gave a solid political speech that inspired the hall, if not the audience at home. His ego, of course, was on full display. He reminded listeners that he, too, just like Obama, was called inexperienced when he ran for president in 1992. The implication was that he'd proved himself wonderful, and that Barack will as well. The problem is that many American didn't think "wonderful" described his tenure in the White House. Most presidents don't get themselves impeached over lying to a grand jury. Most don't respond to terrorism by taking out an aspirin factory and some weed patches in Afghanistan. And most don't sell the Lincoln bedroom to the highest bidder. Still, Clinton's speech was politically effective. He still knows how to feel our pain, although, at his current astronomical income, he probably feels less of it than before. Or, maybe he just hires someone to feel pain, or describe it to him. Joe Biden also passed muster with a classic Democratic speech portraying the nation as sinking under the weight of special interests and sinister forces in the White House. But Biden also committed the greatest blunder of the night - going after John McCain on national security. He didn't make the case, and suggesting that Barack Obama has better judgment on securing the nation is not an argument that should be advertised. Also, the viciousness of Biden's attack on his "friend," John McCain, may come back to haunt him. While Biden has some admirable qualities, the fact is that he opposed most of the Reagan policies that led to the successful end of the Cold War, opposed Gulf War I, is incredibly soft on the Iranian mullahs, and actually suggested chopping Iraq into little pieces. The words "Biden" and "visionary" are not usually placed together. By attacking McCain so strongly he opened himself to equally strong attacks. It's a fact, though, that conventions rarely matter all that much. The soaring speeches and stinging attacks are usually forgotten within a few days. It's only when something goes very wrong that a permanent impact might be felt. The Democratic wreckage in Chicago in 1968, when the convention was surrounded by violent demonstrators and less-than-disciplined police, did not help the party's image. Nor was it polished four years later, when the Dem convention became so disorganized that George McGovern was forced to make his acceptance speech at 3 a.m. Tonight, though, may count. Barack Obama accepts the nomination in an outdoor setting that already is making some Democrats nervous. Outdoor political rallies are not exactly an American thing. I don't know, maybe he got the idea when he visited Berlin, where that sort of choreography was perfected decades ago. Obama tried to explain yesterday that he wanted the outdoor event in a huge stadium so that all common folk who wanted to attend could do so. That is complete nonsense, of course. You can see it better on TV. The planned rally just reminds us of the grandeur that is The One. He has come to save the world, and a world-sized rally suits his style. But Obama has to deliver. The public has already tired of the empty rhetoric and grand flourishes. Other speakers at his convention seemed larger than their candidate. Now he gets a chance to reintroduce himself. He has sagged in the polls, and he needs this night. August 28, 2008. Permalink
Posted at 7:07 a.m. ET The New York Sun, a small, but influential, and decidedly neo-conservative paper, has not taken kindly to the proceedings in Denver, and feelings are not hidden in today's editorial, which is far more harsh than my own appraisal:
Bubba comes in for some tough words:
And...
Did you feel the knife go in?
That line got a pathetic response from the leftist crowd that is the party's base. Standing up to dictators isn't their specialty.
If I were Barack Obama, I wouldn't count on The Sun's endorsement. They seem to be leaning the other way. August 28, 2008. Permalink
Posted at 7:06 a.m. ET The Los Angeles Times reports on an outrageous attempt by the Obama campaign to stifle basic American freedoms. There have been several stories like this, and they raise profound questions about the way Obama would see the American Constitution, should he by chance get elected in November:
And...
Gee. The sky must be falling.
This may be a taste of what we can expect if anyone dares to criticize President Obama.
The McCain people should jump on this. Frame it as an example of hack politics at its worst, which it is. The Obama people have an inflated view of themselves and their candidate. Someone has to let the air out of their balloon. August 28, 2008. Permalink
WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 27, 2008
11:20 p.m. ET: On balance, the Democrats had a good night. At least they got to some issues. However, one thing you couldn't help notice was that Barack Obama, presumably the star, looked awfully small compared with the others on the stage. We were told by Bill Clinton and Joe Biden that Obama should be president, but their arguments were unconvincing and vague. They couldn't point to one major accomplishment of Obama's that the public knew, or that was truly impressive or dramatic. This isn't, after all, a race for the presidency of the senior class. The end of Biden's speech has already generated some negative heat among TV analysts. Going after John McCain on national security is like going after Michael Phelps on swimming. Reasonable criticism was fair, but Biden's attack was far too strong, and didn't inspire confidence in Biden's own instincts. You can't describe a man as a friend one minute, as Biden did of McCain, then attack him so viciously the next, while still calling him "John." Doesn't play well.
Biden has finished. Good political speech, and brief enough, for a change.
The crawl under the Fox picture tells us that Obama will come down to the podium after the Biden speech. There is precedent for the top of the ticket making an appearance before his acceptance address. I believe Kennedy did it in 1960, and Obama is trying to present himself as the second JFK, which he is not. 10:27 p.m. ET: Biden will speak in minutes. The convention is watching a film about him now. Very personal, rather effective. But, ultimately, it's the top of the ticket that counts. Joe Biden's son has just been introduced. He will introduce the nominee. The son, who is attorney general of Delaware, was introduced as "Captain," because he is a reservist. That is understandable, but somewhat inappropriate. 10:11 p.m. ET: The convention awaits Joe Biden, who will give his speech accepting the vice-presidential nomination. Based on his past speeches, I suggest ordering out for enough meals to last through the weekend. 9:42 p.m. ET: Michael Dukakis was just interviewed on Fox. I learned he is still alive. 9:26 p.m. ET: Clinton has just finished. I must say that he confirmed his status as one of the best political speakers of our time. A rousing speech. Hollow in substance, of course, with some ridiculous claims, but a rousing speech nonetheless. How effective? It may help Obama a bit, but speeches like this tend to be forgotten quickly.
Fascinating moment: Lots of cheering about what Obama will do for peace, health and other good things. But when Clinton said that Obama would stand up to our adversaries, the crowd gave only a tepid response. Pretty much tells the story of the Democratic Party over the last generation.
--------------------------------------- REAL-WORLD ALERT: From The Times of London: "A new Cold War between Russia and the West grew steadily closer today after the Kremlin gave a warning about 'direct confrontation' between American and Russian warships in the Black Sea. Dmitri Peskov, a spokesman for Vladimir Putin, the Prime Minister, declared that Russia was taking 'measures of precaution' against American and Nato naval ships. 'Let’s hope we do not see any direct confrontation in that,' he said." And let's hope the-one-we're-been-waiting-for notes this crisis, potentially very critical, in his acceptance speech tomorrow night.
CIVILIZATION AND ITS DISCONTENTS Posted at 6:20 p.m. ET Ms. Hillary's speech did not pacify the most passionate of her loyalists. The term "kamikaze" comes to mind. The Washington Post reports that bitterness endures, and that travel plans are being made. Hard to know if this will last, but clearly the Obama camp will not have a complete "one land, one leader" moment. There's one land, leader to be decided:
Truth be told, this happens fairly often at conventions. At the 1976 Republican convention, Ronald Reagan conceded defeat to President Gerald R. Ford, but, in his speech, barely noted Ford's existence. Jimmy Carter, unblessed memory, won the election. And at the 1980 Democratic convention, Edward R. Kennedy threw in the towel in his bid to take the nomination from Carter, but ice formed on his lips as he did it. Ronald Reagan won the election. Divided parties suffer from the divisions, and often lose by narrow margins. In 1968, a bitterly divided Democratic Party nominated Vice President Hubert H. Humphrey for the top job, only to see him lose by a whisker to the never-popular Richard M. Nixon, by then a political retread. The Dems who stayed home on election day made the difference. So unity can count - a lesson both parties might note. Some Hillaristas aren't listening:
Some will, as Cold War reporters liked to say about people who lived in dictatorships, vote with their feet:
Didn't Aretha Franklin sing about R-E-S-P-E-C-T. Not too much respect for the nominee from many of the Hillary delegates. And,as noted below, Bill will be skipping the nominee's speech. The key point, to be determined, is how much effect all this will have in November. August 27, 2008. Permalink
Why doesn't he just put on a McCain pin and get it over with?
Go back to school and learn something.
TRACKERS Posted at 1:35 p.m. ET Both trackers are now out. As reported here earlier, McCain has taken the lead, although only a one-point lead, in the Rasmussen survey. However, Gallup, which had McCain two points ahead yesterday, today has him one point behind. Averaging both polls today, it's a tie. A distinguished scholar cautioned me that it takes about a week to identify trends in tracking polls, and I agree. We report them every day here with that understanding. Also, polls results will vary from day to day due to the margin of error and ordinary statistical noise. Bottom line, it's an incredibly tight race. There is no sign yet that Obama has benefited in the least from his naming of Joe Biden as his vice-presidential pick, or from the start of his convention. Poll results tomorrow should start to reflect any impact that Hillary Clinton's appearance had. McCain names his v.p. choice at the end of the week. His convention begins Monday. August 27, 2008. Permalink
BULLETIN AT 9:30 A.M. ET: First tracker of the day is out. Rasmussen, which had Obama up three points two days ago, and had the race tied yesterday, now shows McCain up by one. Cautionary note: This does not take into account last night's speech by Hillary Clinton, which was shown on all networks. We might see any impact from that tomorrow morning. LAST NIGHT Posted at 7:04 a.m. Thanks to Hillary Clinton, the Democrats had a good night last night. Her speech, carried by all the networks, did what it had to do. The tracking polls probably won't pick up any effect until results are published tomorrow. Today's results will reflect polling taken a bit too early. But, on reflection, I still think there's a disconnect between today's Democratic Party and the country. I had the feeling that the party continues to talk down to the American people. Americans realize there are real threats out there, but you'd never know it from the Democratic convention. National security is lumped in with every other issue, as if survival was on the same priority level as building better bridges. There is, as there has been in the party for a generation, a lack of maturity. We're told that tonight will be "national-security night" in Denver. But what will they say? The base of the party is indifferent to national security. Having a national-security night is like giving a dinner for some local politician who's been ignored for years. There'll be nice speeches, and everything will be forgotten tomorrow morning. The key is how this is playing with the American people. Well, first off, Hillary proved herself a better campaigner last night than either Obama or Biden, which was clearly her intent. Biden is an okay, although somewhat abrasive speaker. We'll hear him tonight, but he's speaking on the same night as Bill Clinton. The matchup reminds me of a comment that Bing Crosby once made about Frank Sinatra. A talent like that, Crosby said, comes along once in a lifetime. "But why did it have to be my lifetime?" I'd imagine that Biden will have that same view of Clinton tonight. There are reports that Obama's handlers want him to tone down his soaring rhetoric when he makes his acceptance speech tomorrow night. More nuts 'n bolts. Prove to the people you understand the issues. Don't sound like a Sunday pastor. Well, okay, but that assumes there's some beef there. We'll have to see. It's perfectly clear from the polls that Obama has worn out part of his welcome. We may soon find out if there's a "new Obama," like the "new Nixon." The new Nixon was elected in 1968, but things eventually didn't work out. Stay tuned. And watch the action in the trackers to see the effect on public opinion. August 27, 2008. Permalink
Posted at 7:01 a.m. ET One of the subtexts of this campaign is the role of the mainstream media, which once again goes to extremes to embarrass itself. Tony Blankley, British born and an astute observer of American politics, has some thoughts about the institution that one English press lord called "the froth estate." Consider:
Such warmth from Tony.
And the predictable crowd did its predictable thing:
And they couldn't contain themselves.
I hope Biden didn't accidentally read this. The man has pride.
Blankley is right, of course. Americans are learning what the term "in the tank" means, and the in-the-tank media continues its downward spiral in public esteem. MSNBC, for example, has essentially taken itself off the list of serious media outlets by becoming a subdivision of the Obama campaign, a situation so awkward and unprofessional that some of their "talent" had an on-the-air spat about it yesterday. But now Americans have alternative media. The First Amendment may save the nation yet. August 27, 2008. Permalink
|
"What you see is news. What you know is background. What you feel is opinion."
SUBSCRIPTIONS: Subscriptions to URGENT AGENDA are voluntary. Why subscribe to something you're getting free? To help guarantee that you'll continue to get it at all. Subscriptions sustain us. Payments are through PayPal and are secure, but you do not have to sign up for a PayPal account. Credit cards are fine. FOR A ONE-YEAR ($48) SUBSCRIPTION, CLICK: FOR A SIX-MONTH ($26) SUBSCRIPTION, CLICK: IF YOU DON'T WISH A SET SUBSCRIPTION, BUT PREFER TO DONATE ANY OTHER AMOUNT TO SUSTAIN URGENT AGENDA, CLICK:
POWER LINE: It's a privilege for me to post periodic pieces at Power Line. To go to Power Line, click here. To link to my Power Line pieces, go here.
THE CURRENT QUESTION Last week we asked, What do you think will be the single greatest crisis facing the new president in his first month in office? You can view the answers here.
What would you like to see President Bush accomplish in his last five months in office? If you'd like to send us your thoughts, click:
CONTACT: YOU CAN E-MAIL US, AS FOLLOWS: If you have wonderful things to say about this site, if it makes you a better person, please click: If you have a general comment on anything you see here, or on anything else that's topical, please click:
FAVORITE SITES (List will grow) Power Line
|